Great X-pectations by Jason M. Bourgeois

There’s a Black Sun on the Rise...

Someday, I will be hunted down by some songwriter who’s tune I mangle for a witty title. Until that day, I make profuse apologies to Creedence Clearwater Revival.

If you have been following the X-Verse mess lately, you’re aware of X-Men: Black Sun, or as my friends and I have taken to calling it, "BS". Which is a fairly accurate description of the series.

BS was meant to be a celebration/event of the All-New All- Different X-Men’s 25th anniversary. And on that level, I suppose it succeeded. It had the obligatory fight between the originals (what is left of them) and the All-New team from Giant- Size X-Men #1/Uncanny #94.

More importantly it seems, this was also used to bring back the name of Magik. This kind of undermines the whole ‘celebration’ since Magik was never an X-Man. Oh, and if you’re worried about spoilers, I suggest you stop reading now, since eventually I shall reveal who Magik is.

Claremont wrote the first and final issues of this miniseries, and while the storyline itself may be highly contrived, it is a definite improvement over the core books. Scary, huh? The other three books were just plotted by him, with scripts by Len Wein, Roy Thomas, and Louise Simonson. All fair choices for the event, due to high involvement with the X-Characters over the years. Wein wrote Giant Size X-Men, Thomas handled the original X-Men during the late 60’s, and Simonson with the New Mutants and X-Factor.

The art is passable as well. I’ve come to expect sub par art on events like this, which is rather sad. The art probably would have fared better if it had not been rendered in really bright colours. Kind of kills the mood for a story with demons running around.

Now for the whole point of the miniseries. The return of Magik. How did they handle it? Rather well, I’d say. They gave ample hints as to the character’s true identity, all leading up to the big revelation that Magik...is not Illyana. Yup, you heard it here last. Magik is Amanda Sefton, Nightcrawler’s occasional girlfriend, who was last seen running the show in Limbo, and wielding Magik’s soulsword. So the revelation all came together rather well.

All in all, not a horrid series. Not a great one either. Perfectly OK to skip this one. Especially since each of the three middle issues generally have the same plot. Demons attack original member of the X-Men, Magik shows up to try and stop them, fails, moves on to her next target.

There were also some major continuity problems with this story, the largest of which being when the heck it took place. The editor finally revealed online that it took place prior to X- Men vol. 2, #100, for anyone who is interested and/or confused. This is something that should have been mentioned in the book itself, rather than an online revelation, reaching only a small number of fans.

Next month, I will either be overjoyed at the return of Rachel Summers over in Cable (Buy this book! It’s got the same addictive chemicals in Ellis comics, and no Liefeld art!), or droning on about the recent editorial changes at Marvel.


    Jason M Bourgeois

[more X-pectations] [Back to Collector Times]
[Prev.] [Return to Comics] [Disclaimer] [Next]


Copyright © 2000 Jason M. Bourgeois

foenix13@aol.com

About the Author