Comic Book Movie Overload?
By Clayton Harriman

I was at a family get-together the other day and I was talking with my uncles about The Hulk coming onto DVD this week. The conversation moved to comic-book movies in general, and how there are essentially two types; ones that everyone knows are comic-book movies (Spiderman, Hulk, X-Men), and those that aren't (Matrix, LXG, Road to Perdition, Ghost World). The former obviously comes with a built in fan-base to help sales while the latter doesn't have this advantage. Those comic-book movies that the majority of the public don't realize are inspired from comic literature have to make it on their own merits, and *IF* they become box office success stories, nobody really connects them to the comic-book world. Hence, what we're seeing is the wide-spread stereotyping of comic-book movies as spandex-wearing PG-13 heroes.

Now that I'm done telling you what you already know, let me tell you about the meat of my conversation with my uncle, it went something like this . . .

ME: . . . So, the new Hulk DVD comes out on Friday, I hope it has lots of new cool stuff in it.

UNCLE: . . . I dunno, I never saw it at the theatre, there are just too many comic book movies, I think people are getting sick of them. !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Hold the phone! Have comic book (inspired) movies gotten to the point where people can classify them as such? And then go on to decide that they will or will not see them if they are related to a comic book?

The answer, I believe is YES. Unfortunate as it sounds, there are so many comic book inspired movies being produced that the well is being run dry. Don't get me wrong, I love watching comic-book movies, and a part of me says keep on making them until the public is so sick of them that they end up being straight to video junk (Marvel "movies" pre-Spiderman). The big blockbuster success stories that Spiderman, Xmen and Xmen 2 brought in probably won't be repeated.

However, even I was surprised at the lack of blockbuster success that Daredevil brought in. The Hulk, with international and DVD sales, will prove to be a blockbuster over time. I just hope that the mountains of price-reduced Hulk Movie toys won't make retailers a little leery the next go-round. (As a side note, I really think that more Hulk villains should have been produced, and a quality cartoon to market as well). There is hope for the comic-book movie scene and it comes (for me) not in the spandex wearing heroes, but in expanding the genre.

I was on ComicBookResources.com this morning and I read that the new Man-Thing movie is scheduled to be released next summer. This took me by surprise because I hadn't even heard that this movie was in production (maybe because it was filmed totally in Australia) AND because Marvel Studios is going to be heavily hyping this as a HORROR MOVIE!

Yes, the House of Ideas is going to be putting out a horror movie for the public, something that I hope will get people to see comic-book movies in a different light. Hopefully when HellBlazer and Ghostrider eventually make it to theatres, they'll be able to get people to think of comic-book literature in a broader light.

-- Clayton Harriman


[Back to Collector Times]
[Prev.] [Return to Comics] [Disclaimer] [Next]

Text Copyright © Clayton Harriman

E-mail: clay_world@hotmail.com