"The Alamo"

    Movie Review by Sidra Roberts

8.7 out of 10

I'm Texan. I've been looking forward to this movie since I saw the first preview for it. It didn't matter that a subsidiary of Disney was producing it. It was a new movie about the Alamo. And what good Texan doesn't want to see a movie about the Alamo? For those of you non-Texans, you're probably wondering why we want to do see a movie in which we lose.

The point of it is not that we lost. It's that we told them to go to hell, and held out valiantly while telling them such. We didn't surrender, and we held them back long enough to muster an army to defeat them. Plus it just served to further piss us off and make us want to kick their butts all the more. The massacre at Goliad also served the same purpose, but they conveniently forget to mention that in the movie.

As far as historical accuracy goes, it's fairly good. They, of course, make up stuff and make conjectures on what people said in the mission. My only real genuine complaint is that they focus a little bit too much on Davy Crockett for my tastes. Crockett was a failing politician from Tennessee who got stuck at the wrong place at the wrong time.

Another amusing thing is the movie's writers or director attempting to show "War brutal. War bad!" in a movie about the Alamo. This is the Alamo, people! Not a Vietnam movie. The idea that they're trying to make a big war bad thing out of Alamo is laughable. This is how you know that who ever was responsible was not from Texas.

Overall it's an entertaining movie and I'd recommend for any and everyone to go see it. And yes, I'm Texan and I'm biased. I'm also damn proud of it, too.


[Back to Collector Times]
[Prev.] [Return to Reviews] [Disclaimer] [Next]


Text Copyright © 2004 Sidra Roberts

About Sidra