American Splendor: Our Movie Year

Review By: Jamie Coville

American Splendor: Our Movie Year
by Harvey Pekar, various artists.
Publisher: Ballantine Books
Price: $16.95 USA, $23.95 CAN.
Format: Oversized 174 Pages, B/W.

For those that don't know what American Splendor is, it's a comic book about the everyday mundane things that happen in Harvey Pekar's life. During the 70's when there were all sorts of fantasy superhero comics, barbarian titles, ultra dramatic romance books and radical underground comics Harvey thought of doing a comic that was grounded in reality. He figured (correctly) that comics were just words and pictures and they could be about anything. Harvey had met Robert Crumb due to their mutual love for old jazz records and later on he became the big star of the underground comic scene. Harvey discussed his idea with Crumb and showed him some sample comics he made using stick figures and Crumb thought they were really good. He agreed to draw them and off they went.

Since then Harvey Pekar has continued to publish one issue of American Splendor every year. He uses a variety of artists for his stories, but Gary Dumm has done the majority of the work. The book pays for itself but not much else. He continued working as a file clerk for the government (Veteran Office), but did get some fame from being invited onto the David Letterman show a few times in the early 80's. Critically speaking his biggest claim to fame was an original graphic novel called Our Cancer Year devoted to him getting cancer and beating it. All throughout this period he was trying to get a movie deal for his comic and finally one panned out.

This book takes place during the year American Splendor was filmed and advertised. There are a variety of short stories most of them about stuff regarding the movie. From those that optioned it, him hanging around the set while it was filmed, his health problems after they stopped filming. They also show him and his family flying all over the world doing promotions for it, particularly the Sundance Film Festival. He also does some mini-biographies of the Jazz musicians he enjoys.

The book is really interesting. I've read some American Splendor before and it's always a mixed bag of entertaining and dull stories. The movie element makes this book more entertaining. Only problem is half way into the book Harvey begins to repeat himself a lot. I found myself having to force myself to read the same story over and over again. But after the half way point the stories go back to more original ground and becomes entertaining again.

There are 10 different artists in here, among them Robert Crumb, Frank Stack, Joe Zable, Dean Haspiel and of course Gary Dumm. Gary gets to show off his ability to draw a variety of styles as it's mainly just him during the last chunk of the book. He does a good job of making everything look different each time. Die Hard superhero fans may not like the art style, but if you're brave enough to read something outside the big two, this book is something you should read. Harvey needs the money! He's got a wife and kid to support and his pension won't do it. Despite the movie he is not rich, nor is everything rosy.

I give the book an 8 out of 10.

Regards,

Jamie Coville


[Back to Collector Times]
[Prev.] [Return to Comics] [Disclaimer] [Next]


Text Copyright © 2005 Jamie Coville

About the Author

E-mail: jcoville@kingston.net