Capsule Reviews

By Chris Karnes

First off, my CONGRATULATIONS go out to Sidra and Zack and their families. I've met Sidra and the Roberts and I know Zack is a real lucky guy. I wish the happy couple laughter and joy in the coming years. Best wishes!

Next, I've never sought out to really pimp anything, but now I have to make an exception. If the recent big-screen Catwoman movie soured you, check out this website . . .
http://www.catwoman-copycat.com/

This fan-flick is slated for a June 15 release date (the same day as Batman Begins comes out), but there's a trailer up on the site now. There's also a gallery and a message board. Please check it out and tell 'em what you think. They would really love your feedback.

Now, on with the reviews . . .

Action Comics #827 (DC) -- Fan favorite writer Gail Simone teams up with ex-fan favorite artist John Byrne for a new Superman arc. Byrne is also doing art chores on DC's Blood of the Demon and Doom Patrol, too; where I think his artwork is a bit more dimensional. I looked forward to seeing this creative combo, but afterward felt a bit less enthralled than I had hoped. I thought it was just average. Oh, a new Daily Planet photographer is introduced (ho-hum), and there's a "is he, or isn't he?" mystery with the villain. There is some undertones that Simone is trying to trying to be a "new broom" and get Clark Kent back to the Daily Planet. I'll stick with it, but I thought this effort was just a little on the mediocre side.

Batman: Dark Detective #2 (DC) -- The pros: I like Engleheart's acknowledgment/references to past Batman lore; telling us the giant penny in the Batcave came from a case called "The Penny Plunderers," (it really did) and, a picture of the Kathy Kane Batwoman hanging on the wall of the Batcave. Marshall Rogers & Terry Austin are showing some flashes of great artwork.

The cons: In some other places, the artwork seems less-detailed and rushed. The pacing of the story is moving a bit too slow, and for each issue so far, the main setting has only been one location. Also, it's a bit creepy, even for Batman, to keep one of Silver St. Cloud's shoe in a glass showcase. Two issues in to this six-issue series, I've accepted that I won't like this as much as I had initially hoped. Still, for nostalgia purposes, I feel compelled to go back, even though you can't go home again.

Jon Sable Freelance: Bloodtrail #1 (IDW) -- Or, can you go home again? Mike Grell's Jon Sable was one of my favorite comics from the '80s with timely stories and great art. Here, Grell is still at the top of his game and hasn't missed a beat. The artwork is absolutely stunning and the story is off to a decent start, too. There's an opening violent sequence with a usual two-page Grell splash that's awesome and feels like you're sitting first row in an action movie. The supporting cast of characters is back too, as is Sable's alter-ego, child's author, B.B. Flemm. Good stuff.

Girls #1 (Image) -- And now for something completely different. This is by the Luna Brothers who recently did the interesting Ultra series. My take on this was "Twin Peaks" meets "Clerks." Our story opens in the small town of Pennystown, with the main character, Ethan starting his day masturbating to a magazine, and his day goes down hill from there (maybe I should've also included the movie "American Beauty"). Ethan has huge communication problems with women, the locals and a new one visiting from out of town. His problems get worse after an incident in a bar, and then, encountering a nude woman on the side of the road on his way home. From there, the story suddenly becomes a mystery.

The dialogue is sharp (but had a honest and real feel to it) and there's a fair share of adult language and content. Obviously, not recommended for children.

Zorro #1 (Papercutz) -- But here's something for kids. Papercutz has already dusted off the Hardy Boys and Nancy Drew and now Zorro is getting resurrected. Some of my online friends are huge Zorro fans, mostly due to the reruns of the Guy Williams series that reran late nights on the Disney Channel. Like the other comics Papercutz puts out, the artwork is manga-ish and the stories will run over two or three issues. Don McGregor, who wrote Zorro for Topps Comics, returns to write the character here. I'm a mild Zorro fan myself. I thought this was okay, but not great; storytelling: decent, artwork: mildly interesting. The $2.95 might be steep for kids, but I suspect it's the older Zorro fans that will go for this.

Green Lantern: Rebirth #6/Green Lantern #1 (DC) -- Okay, let's get one thing out of the way, NO ONE, and I mean, no one, gets away with punching Batman in the jaw.

Whew. That said, so Hal is back and all is well. Well, almost. Coast City is a ghost town, and some are treating Hal, well, like a ghost. I'm still getting used to seeing Hal back to normal and as a GL again. The shock of that was pretty much how I felt reading these books. Van Sciver is an outstanding and underrated artist. Still, I didn't see much happening on the outset. There's a new blonde pilot introduced as Capt. Jillian Pearlman, which looks like a possible future love interest.

Young Avengers #4 (Marvel) -- Ah, the old "you-can't-go-back-in-time-cause-you'll-disrupt-everything" story. Still, any Marvel book that has Jessica Jones in it is a "must read" for me. And, I've always had a soft spot for teen hero groups. This was a way-too-fast read, but still enjoyable. And I don't know which character is my favorite because I like them all. The "homosexuals in comics" debate is still going on in the letters column.

Some bullet comments . . .

DC Special: The Return of Donna Troy #1 (DC) -- Glad she's back, didn't think she was really dead, and shaping up to be a good "brought back from the dead" story if they don't muck it up. The new DC logo doesn't do much for me, but I suppose it was due.

Omac Project #2 (DC) -- I wasn't a Sasha fan to start with and with Batman deeply kissing her here and Silver St. Cloud in Batman: Dark Detective, Bats is getting around this month.

Solo (DC) -- It's a great showcase/anthology book. Pricey, but well done.

DID'JA KNOW: DC mini series, Villains, United has revamped Catman, a old Batman villain. Catman first appeared in Detective Comics #311. His main gimmick was an orange cape which magically gave him nine lives.


[Back to Collector Times]
[Prev.] [Return to Comics] [Disclaimer] [Next]


Text Copyright © 2005 Chris Karnes

E-mail: ussentinel@yahoo.com