Artistic License by Joe Singleton

We Have A Winner!

Yup, the contest is over, the winner is . . .

Jay from Minnesota!

We have his real name and all, but that's how he requested we identify him.

Jay asked me to take a look at one of the oldest characters in comics. One I've taken a shot at, before, but only in a peripheral way, as a member of the Batman family.

Robin . . . the archetypal sidekick. Young, impertinent and precocious. Don't you just HATE him? I did, growing up. I was a kid when Batman was on TV and Burt Ward's Robin was the lens through which I saw the character.

Later, when I got interested in comics, something changed. That change was in Detective Comics, during the short but excellent run when Steve Englehart, Marshall Rodgers and Terry Austin had the book. Robin only showed up late in the run, and only for a short time, but it was memorable to me. Especially the scene with Batman and Robin sparring in the Batcave. Not a match, more like a father and son, or brothers, testing one another. It was friendly, they laughed. Yes, Batman was laughing and smiling. Near the end, Robin gets a call from Wonder Girl (nice one-panel cameo of Wonder Girl) and has to go off to join the Teen Titans on a mission or something. Turns out that was the end of the Titans, for awhile. Good riddance, I say. That series of the Teen Titans was unreadable!!!

Of course, the next time I encountered Robin, was in the New Teen Titans. And even though he was as goofy looking as ever, he was not the Robin of the TV series or other appearances. More like that Robin from Detective Comics. Young, but not a child. Still dressing like one, though. Took way too long to get him out of that outfit.

Robin's costume is one of those mistakes that no one seemed to want to correct. It's just embarassing. The poor kid was made to parade around in a red vest and green sequin panties for decades! And those shoes!!! Argh!

It would take awhile before we got a new Robin costume, two whole "generations" of Robin would have to pass, before the third, Tim Drake, got to wear something a little more presentable. But, that's only if you remain in the post-Crisis continuity. Fortunately, we're free to roam further afield than that!

Once upon a time, there was another Robin. He started his career, cavorting around the rooftops and alleyways of Gotham City is 1940. Thanks to a neat trick, he apparently aged at a vastly slower rate than his contemporaries. This is obvious, because by the 1970s, he was in his adulthood, no middle age. This Robin was the one from the old comics, approximately ending when Batman got the yellow oval on his shirt, or thereabouts. This Robin was Dick Grayson, like we all know, but when he reappeared in Justice League of America #55, he was almost as badly dressed as the last time he'd been seen.

He's the one on the left. He'd borrowed a few items from his mentor's closet, obviously, but he hadn't learned any sense of style at that point. The mask, chest emblem and cape are just bloody awful. Later, someone with a little better fashion sense adapted his old colors into a style not a lot different from the one designed for Tim Drake. The cape is still a little bright, but if he's careful, it won't make him too much of a target. Yeah, right....

At the time, this Robin costume was the best they'd come up with. Still needed something, though. One of the nice things about multiple Earths was, it gave writers and artists a place to experiment. In a lot of ways, I miss those days. All the alternate worlds kept things from feeling too crowded. The Earth's a crowded place in DC Comics, these days.

The second Robin (excluding the whole Earth-1/Earth-2 thing) was Jason Todd and, visually, he was nothing new. Dark hair, short, young, fit the old costumes so what the hell......

I liked some of the things about Jason. He wasn't a "good boy". He was the son of a criminal and he tried to steal the rims off the batmobile. The kid had balls.

So then, Frank Miller comes along and tells us in his masterpiece Batman: The Dark Knight Returns that Jason gets killed. Screwy. But, in Dark Knight, we get to meet yet another Robin. This one has much in common with the third Robin, in that she sought out Batman, not the other way around. Her family was intact, at the time she chose to become Robin. She had the costume made for her, choosing the classic style, but it works better on a girl than a boy, anyway. Some Robin. I figure.

Carrie Kelley was an excellent Robin. She had all the impertinance and recklessness a good Robin needs. She didn't follow orders very well.

I don't know what the future holds for Carrie Kelley. Maybe we'll never see her again, but I kinda hope someone who works on the Justice League cartoon reads this and takes this little suggestion.... Carrie Kelley...Robin-BEYOND. :P

I tried to stick to the Batman Beyond styling. Keep it sleek and simple. I figure the wings retract, like Batman's.

For a moment, let's go back in time...years ago, I had an idea for a Batman series, but I never found the hook I needed to tell a really compelling story for it. The idea would be to do an Elseworlds style Batman story, set in the days when Batman first appeared, the late 30s/early 40s. When it came to costumes, rather than just mimicking the Golden Age art, I thought about designing costumes that would look like they'd be made in that period. With Batman, I didn't change much. His costume is one of the perfect comic costumes, after all. The cape and mask, however, needed a few touches. I figure leather for all the black bits. Probably with some padding or layering. The mask is like a wrestling mask, laces in the back, or straps with buckles. Nothing too big, but there to make the mask fit snugly. The cape would be attached to the extended neck of the cowl, giving a double layer of leather, there. I didn't draw it, but I think the gloves should also have some laces at the wrist, to snug them up.

For Robin's suit, I had a few definite ideas. My conception of a Golden Age Robin is inspired, in part, by Jason Todd and the old Bowery Boys movies. I could just picture a street kid in 1939 with a tire iron, sweating and cursing trying to get the lug nuts off the Batmobile. An orphan child of two murdered circus performers, a runaway from the county orphanage where the circus folk dumped him. Yeah, that worked.

But, would a street kid, even the child of circus folk dress in that embarassing little costume? Hell, no! One of the things American kids in those days longed for was to get out of short pants! So, my Robin costume had to take those things into consideration. Even so, I wanted to keep the basic outfit recognizable. I did a little research and found some things I could work with. The vest, I got from a fencing vest. Padded and layered, it's designed to be light, yet give some protection against blunt force and possibly even turn a blade. It's double-breasted, so there's a double-layer of protection over the center of the chest and abdomen. The outer layer would be leather. The green short sleeves would be padded, but less heavily, allowing for more freedom of movement. Robin's a boy, he's acrobatic, but nowhere near Batman's class, so he can't necessarily rely on his ability to dodge, etc., so padding is the difference between a bruise and a broke bone.

I gave him a utility belt like Batman's, not the pared down "kiddie" version he'd always had before. No sequin panties, this time. Black's good enough for the old man, it's good enough for Robin. Helps hide the athletic supporter and cup, anyway. Notice I gave him long sleeves and leggings. Gotham City is in the north, and has long cold winters, can't be running around dressed like a pedophile's dream in two feet of snow. And, no more friggin booties! The boots I designed are meant to be flexible, but tough enough to give some protection. They lace up the back, to keep them snug enough for an acrobat's footing. The green would be a dark color, evergreen, something like that. No kelly green glaring out of the night, but the green of the forest. The cape is longer than the classic Robin's cape and reversable, like Tim Drake's. One side dark green, the other the same muted gold as the sleeves and leggings.

Of course, we finally got a new Robin suit, in Batman continuity, with the suit designed for Tim Drake. It accomplished the goal of eliminating the worst weaknesses of the original Robin suit, closing the tunic, getting rid of the sequin/scale mail trunks and the little fairy booties. When it was introduced, it was said to be composed of so many layers of Kevlar it would have weighed like 100 pounds! The cape was several layers of Kevlar, too, and added to the weight. I guess they later revised that the material was some kind of alternative to Kevlar developed by Wayne Industries, to reduce the immense weight penalty of Kevlar. Whatever. I don't mind the body armor, but too much makes it unwieldy. Armor the most critical parts, but the point is to get out of the way of bullets. In the original design, and for years after, Tim's boots had the split toe of Japanese "tabi" boots, in the ninja style, but this has fallen out of favor in recent years. Mostly, I like this design, though the belt is impractical. The staff weapon is cool, but an automatic opening and closing telecscoping staff would be impractical, as well. The segments would have to be too thin and weak to serve as a staff, except the segments with the mechanism. The balance would be poor and it just wouldn't work. But, it looks cool, so leave it alone.

For a short time, Tim was out as Robin and Batman had taken one of Tim's friends, the daughter of the villain The Cluemaster. Stephanie had a costumed identity, for awhile, as The Spoiler, which she took up in order to stop her father. She blamed him for her crappy childhood and she wanted to stop him. At some point along the way, Batman saw her potential and began working with her, training her and eventually allowed her to become Robin. Unfortunately, she was killed by Black Mask, or Leslie Tomkins, depending on what you read. I don't read any of the bat-books, right now, so I can't say for sure.

With all that's changed in Tim's life, lately -Stephanie's death and his father's, especially- it might be time for him to make some changes and in comics, that always needs new duds. Again, I wouldn't want to change the basic Robin layout, the color scheme just works so well, regardless of what you've seen in the movies. In the dark, all colors are black, dammit! All I did was add a few "Ultimate" style touches to the suit. I decided to lose some of the pointless detainl, like the little pods on the gloves and short sleeves. I figure the winter version has long sleeves in place of the short sleeves. It's up to the writers and artists to show us the changes of the seasons, otherwise you end up with Ultimate Spider-Man, which hasn't showed the change of even ONE season in the 3 years it's been published.

Anyway, back to Robin. The gauntlet gloves are classic, and they stay. The boots I adapted from the Teen Titans cartoon series and some real boots I've seen at cons and online. I gave him a utility belt with usable pouches, too.

I didn't stray into Nightwing or Tim's possible future as Batman, because that would break out of the "single character" criteria for the contest and it just complicates things.

As for the contest entries that didn't win, I plan on mining that list for column fodder, so keep an eye out here for your suggestions. I can't say when I'll do which characters or anything, but I'll certainly try to credit whoever suggested it.

See you next month!

Discuss this and other Artistic License topics at the Artistic License Forum.


[more Artistic License] [Back to Collector Times]
[Prev.] [Return to Comics] [Disclaimer] [Next]


Copyright © 2005 Joe Singleton

About the Author