Campbell's Soup Part Two
The Super Hero of a Thousand Faces

by Jesse N. Willey

Special Thanks to J.M. DeMatteis

   
Last month, I used this space to do some pretty simple explanation of Joseph Campbell's monomyth theory and discussed whether or not popular media characters could be considered mythology. This month I'm going to discuss the order of the hero's journey. Can you have a myth that doesn't start with the miraculous birth and doesn't end in the rebirth? Campbell himself argued you could, provided that enough of the steps were there. His examples used a lot of rather esoteric elements of Indian mythology. In terms of American science fiction, a good example is Benjamin Sisko.

The 'Death' of Ben Sisko

When we first meet Sisko in the Star Trek: Deep Space Nine episode 'The Emissary' he in battle with the Borg at Wolf 359. It's a flashback to what was shown in Star Trek: The Next Generation episodes 'The Best of Both Worlds'. In the conflagration, Sisko's wife is killed. Then the story jumps ahead in time a few years. Ben becomes disconnected from his life. He no longer travels the stars. The only thing keeping him going was the fact that someone was going to have to take care of his son Jake. In the spiritual sense of the word, he is a walking dead man. Then comes his reassignment to Deep Space Nine, a mission he is not sure he wants.

'Encountering the Wise Man'

In Sisko's case, it is actually a wise woman. Shortly after arriving on the station he goes down to Bajor and meets the Bajoran spiritual leader. She get a psychic feeling from him and reveals to him some of the Bajoran legends of the orbs. She hints that he has some connection to Bajor that he will never truly accept. Sisko has no idea what she is talking about.

'Into the Dark Woods/ The Resurrection of Ben Sisko'

He does an examination of the orbs which leads him to discover the wormhole and the non-linear aliens inside. There is forced to look through his life. He re-meets his wife. He watches as an outside observer to some key moments of his life. He attempts to teach these 'gods' about humanity through baseball. He finally confronts his believed failures at Wolf 359. From there he finally becomes willing to take the Deep Space Nine assignment and more importantly chooses to embrace life.

The Call to Adventure

Sisko encounters many of the other great challenges before and after leaving the wormhole. Just slightly prior to leaving for the wormhole he encounters his dark reflection - Gul Dukat. This echo become more clear as the series goes on. We are eventually introduced to Dukat's illegitimate daughter - who he had to abandon while he was fleeing Bajor. His daughter was the sole survivor of an attack, much as Jake was one of the few survivors of the Borg. The series finale Dukat makes the leap into being the Emissary of Bajoran dark gods - The Pah Wraiths. Thus making this connection about as obvious as they come.

As for the tricksters, Sisko dealt with plenty. There were the Wadi in the episode 'Move Along Home' where the crew are force to play out a day as the characters in what I can only assume was the Gamma Quadrant version of Dungeons and Dragons. There were the aliens who granted wishes - including Sisko's dream of meeting his favorite baseball player. He punched Q in the face. Not to mention his awkward alliances with both Quark and Garak.

Fenna, who was a telepathically induced figment of an out of control telepath, would count as the temptress. Sisko fell madly in love with this illusion. This is almost certainly an intentional retelling of the story of Narcissus. Cassidy Yates would not fit this archetype. She was more of Sisko's solemate. She often helped guide him to make the correct decisions that he didn't want to make.

As for monsters, the closest Sisko faced several. The obvious ones being: 1) The Jem'Hedar. These soldiers of the Dominion were genetically engineered to be smart enough to fly their ships and to kill. They really weren't capable of much else. Save for one or two defective batches, the Jem'Hedar weren't much on higher order thinking. 2) Those all too cute and surprisingly dangerous iconic Star Trek menace - the tribbles. Sure, they seem harmless but they can wipe out entire planetary populations in a manner of days.

The destroyers were obviously The Dominion and the Vorta, their right hands. It's right in the name Dominion. They have no intention of open communication. They want to control, conquer or destroy. They can rule by dependence, as they do to the Jem'Hedar, by fear, as they do the Vorta, by bribery as the did the Cardassians or by force as they attempted to do to the Bajorans. Some might argue that the Dominion is more of a dark reflection of the Federation as a whole however we are not looking at Star Trek as a whole. We are examining the life of one man.

Several circumstances would probably make Kai Wynn the sin of father villain. Or perhaps the sin of the mother. (We'll get to that later.) According to Bajoran religious beliefs, the council of Vedeks, acting on the will of the Prophets, choose the Kai. Thus, the prophets chose Adami Winn, a corrupt, self-centered power hunger woman to lead the hearts and souls of Bajor. Where her soul goes, thus goes all of Bajor. One of Sisko's final great tasks was to expose her for what she was and purge Bajor of her influence. However he was not the one to vanquish her. That would have been against his own new teachings for the Bajoran people.

'Back to the Dark Woods'

Sisko is later forced back into the Dark Woods by the Pah Wraiths in the episode 'Far Beyond the Stars'. Sisko is thrown into the life of Ben Russell an African American science fiction writer of the 1950s. At first he is unaware Sisko ever existed. Then he encounters everyone he knows aboard Deep Space Nine. He begins writing a story which then leads him to battle against 1950s racial barriers and for his own sanity. He is left with a real conundrum however - which is the insanity Ben Sisko or Ben Russell? Which is the dream - the man or the butterfly? This experience, while emotionally maddening, did prepare him for much worse that was to come. Again, as in most Dark Woods stories, Sisko had a choice only this one was a choice to literally chooses ones own reality.

'The Miraculous Birth'

During the final season of Deep Space Nine one of the largest questions of the series was answered. Why was the Emissary to the Bajoran Gods not a Bajoran? What is revealed was the Sisko's father had a previous wife no one knew about. A woman who unbeknownst to him was possessed by one of the Bajoran Prophets. She abandoned them shortly after Ben was born. Not many people know anyone who has gone through that. The miraculous birth clearly holds, however instead of coming at the beginning of the story it didn't come into play until very close to the end.

Sisko The Ascendant

One of the steps I skipped last month - because it is not a part of every mythos and really did not apply to one of the super heroes from my examples was the ascendancy. This is the point where the hero crosses from mortality - not into death but to Godhood. This is Hercules after the thirteen labors or Christ after the resurrection. It is also Sisko upon defeating Gul Dukat and banishing the pah wraiths. After a few brief moments to say goodbye, he is given no choice but to enter the nonlinear realm of the Prophets and learn from them.

As you can see many of the elements of mythos are present in the story of Deep Space Nine. Story and plot are just weaves and patchworks and the order does not have to be in a straightforward progression. Deep Space Nine's writers, at least Ira Behr consciously made Sisko follow Campbell's playbook. Is this idea of mythos unescapable? Can one write a monomyth and not know it? Join us for next - and final course of Campbell's Soup where I try out it out on the works of a willing test subject.

 

[Back to Collector Times]
[Prev.] [Return to Comics] [Disclaimer] [Next]

Text Copyright © 2011 Jesse N. Willey

About Jesse