Welcome to the 3rd edition of Judgment Calls. In this edition, I will be talking about the 3-part mini series JLA: The Nail. The Nail is written and penciled by Alan Davis. This mini-series is an Elseworlds tale. An Elseworlds tale, for those of you who don’t know, is a tale of another world that might have existed, and some other worlds that can’t or shouldn't exist. In this story, John and Martha Kent’s (Superman's parents, well, the people who raised him) truck gets a flat and they don’t have a spare, so they don’t take the drive that fateful day and find Superman’s space ship. So Superman never was.

OK, now we go to the early days of the JLA. Luthor is the mayor of Metropolis, and there is some sort of organized anti-metahuman campaign. In addition, there is a force field surrounding Earth, war has broken out between Apokolips and New Genesis, and the Green Lantern Corps is too busy dealing with that to answer Hal Jordan’s distress call. The world is going down the tubes, everybody is dying, and on top of that, Batman’s lost it. Alan Davis’s view of the world without Superman is horrifying, and it makes you wonder. His writing is great and his art is fantastic, very silverageish, and Mark Farmer’s inks are nice. This mini series is the best one this year so far, and I expect it to take some awards. I think I’ll end with the poem that sums up this mini very well (it also is on the back of the comics):

This is one of the best mini-series I have read. I recommend you pick it up.

I apologize this column was written rather quickly, but still I would like you to check out my Wizardcon '98 report, and my Saving Private Ryan movie review.


[More Judgment Calls] [Back to Collector Times]
[Prev.] [Return to Comics] [Disclaimer] [Next]


Copyright © 1998 Patrick Dunning

About the Author