Review: Marvel Knights Punisher

( Partially a XipeTotec rant )

by Stephane Morrell stephanm@GroupLaurier.CA

Frank Castle was a highly skilled Vietnam veteran turned family man. One day, he and his family were having a picnic in the park, when lo and behold, they fell upon a Mafia rub out. They opened fire on him and his family and killed all but him. When the justice system could do nothing for him, he vowed revenge and became THE PUNISHER.

This is a character I used to follow in his young days, I thoroughly enjoyed the fact that Frank Castle was just a man. ( Okay, he was highly exceptional in his capabilities, but still ... ). He didn't fly, he didn't have laser shooting out of his eyes, and even the fact that he was bulletproof was attributed to his kevlar vest. It was ALMOST a realistic character, other than the fact that he went up against such characters as the Kingpin and Dr. Doom from time to time and he was still included in the same Marvel universe that holds Spider-Man and the Fantastic Four.

But now comes the release of The Marvel Knights: The Punisher. A four part mini put out by Marvel Comics over the last 4 months. In this story arc, The Punisher is resurrected ( after killing himself in prior stories ) by a renegade angel from Heaven. He ends up battling a demon from Hell who was incarcerated in a human body ( Not the same way as Etrigan, "The Demon" ), and finding out that the death of his family and the consequent beginnings of "The Punisher" were actually orchestrated by him, placing The Punisher in a totally supernatural light. I may only be speaking for myself when I say, WHAT A PIECE OF CRAP! They've taken a character that was mostly a shady cross between Rambo and James Bond and turned him into a cross between Rambo and Hellstorm ( who by the way makes a cameo appearance in this series).

Don't get me wrong, SUPER is good, I like the good old superheroes, but characters should not be messed with on such a drastic level. It's an even more stupid story turn than the Energy Superman... I mean, if they had ONLY resurrected him and somehow kept more of what he was all about.

i.e. IT SUCKS :)


[Back to Collector Times]
[Prev.] [Return to Comics] [Disclaimer] [Next]


Copyright © 1999 Stephane Morrell