A Matter of Tradition
By Mike Solko

A war has been brewing for over thirty years, but for the first time since the start of said war it truly feels like something is at stake. Stan Lee and Jack Kirby first introduced us to Charles Xavier and his rival Magneto in Uncanny X-Men #1 and the two factions would engage in battles for decades to come. Xavier dreamed of a world where mutants and humans could live together, yet Magneto believed that such a dream was impossible and that mutants must achieve their place as rulers of humanity. Over hundreds of issues the two sides would face off but there was never any sense of finality to their conflict. Even when Magneto embraced the dream of Xavier it was simply a temporary situation that lasted a few brief years. Chances are if you are a comic fan you’ve read paragraphs like the above over and over, perhaps you’ve even used similar words in explaining the X-Men to a newcomer. The biggest problem with the title, and it’s peripheral titles, running for over 30 years is the fact that while line-ups might change and creators might come and go, the situation for mutants hasn’t. How many times has a character in an X-book spoken of an impending war and the need for mutants to prepare for it? So many times that it has become cliched. With the exception of fictional countries such as Genosha or government programs that fail before they get off the ground this war has been impending for so long that any tension surrounding it is rather flat. Bound by a need for continuity to be maintained with other Marvel titles a war between humanity and mutants is not a likely event.

Ironically enough the mythic war has finally arrived, yet the 30 plus years of build-up have nothing to do with it. Marvel’s new Ultimate X-Men title has been unleashed on the public and this is a book that looks to take no prisoners. While the mainstream X-Men titles have featured characters hiding from "a world that hates and fears them" there rarely seemed like a situation where most of them could not live in hiding if they were careful. Contrast this with the world of the Ultimate X-Men where government created Sentinel robots track down mutants and exterminate them in public. This isn’t a world where two mutants are recruiting mutants to change the future before a war breaks out. This is a world where two mutants are recruiting mutants to save their lives and fight the war that has already begun. Hopefully I’m not stepping on Jason’s toes too much but this month I’m so excited about an X-title for the first time in years I feel the need to talk about it.

As if the tension of absolute mutant intolerance isn’t enough to give the title a dark and desperate atmosphere the characters of Charles Xavier and Magneto are presented as extremely ruthless. While this is nothing new for Magneto both Xavier and his X-Men utilize some shady and ethically arguable tactics while recruiting members for their group. While he has altered memories in the past, I wouldn’t doubt that this new take on Xavier would be willing to take a life if it was necessary to protect his students. Suddenly the chess match between Xavier and Magneto seems much more important and at the same time, it’s not unlikely that a Sentinel could come along and eliminate all the pawns at any moment.

I had large reservations about whether or not Mark Millar and company could come along and revitalize a franchise that has been stagnant at many points in its history. Thanks to the fresh take on continuity, the creative team has taken a promise made in the first Uncanny X-Men comic and make it a reality. The war is here and it’s time to choose a side. While I eagerly await Morrison and Casey’s take on the mainstream continuity X-books for my money Ultimate X-Men is exactly the type of intense drama necessary for such a concept to work. And the last page - wow.

J


[Back to Collector Times]
[Prev.] [Return to Comics] [Disclaimer] [Next]


Copyright © 2000 Mike Solko

frost@ncinternet.net