This Just In
By Jon Morrell

Lord Of The Rings Vs. Bad Taste.
A Peter Jackson face-off.

Watching Lord of the Rings on Thursday night, I couldn't help but be reminded that the man who directed this is also the man who directed many of my favorite b-movies, such as Dead Alive, Meet the Feebles, and the one we'll be focusing on this month, Bad Taste. Sitting in the darkened room, I couldn't help but make connections in the story line... Sure, J.R.R. Tolkien wrote this story around fifty years ago before Peter Jackson was born, but who's to say he didn't base Bad Taste on Lord of the Rings? You laugh now, but wait till I whip out the facts, ladies and gentlemen.

When you look at it, the stories are pretty similar, save for a few small, unimportant things. Before I start the comparison, I'm going to have to put you in a certain mindset. Now, in front of you, you have Lord of the Rings in all it's glory... remove the ring from the story. That’s right! The magic ring, forget about it! Now we can start.

Frodo Vs. Derek(spoken with a New Zealander accent) - Frodo Baggins, who is always getting into trouble, gets stabbed, poked at and infected with the dark rider plague (That’s probably not what it’s called, but you know what I mean!) and no matter how much shit he goes through, he always stands up again. With all his limbs. Derek, Bad Tastes protagonist falls off a cliff early in the movie, hitting his head on every jagged rock on the way down and is not to be seen for another 10 minutes. He then head butts a bird and gets up only to realize there’s a big crack in the back of his head and his brains are oozing out, no problem... he just puts a hat on or ties a tie around his head and he's fine! Just like Frodo would do.

Ozzy Vs. Gimli - Ok, so you have Ozzy, the stereotypical 80s metalhead of Bad Taste(no, it’s not Ozzy Osbourne, just some fruitcake named Ozzy.) He has the hair, he has the muscle, he has the muscle car and most important of all, he listens to heavy metal music. Now you have Gimli, he's got missing teeth, long hair and a beard, and a total reckless attitude, I mean this guy will head-butt your mother while burning your house down... just like a metal head would do. If I saw this dude in a bar, I'd most likely crap myself. If Lord Of the Rings was set in present time, he'd be a metal head... trust me!

Old Man Alien Vs. Saruman - Old Man Alien, he has no name but if you've seen the movie, you'd know that he's the leader of the alien pack. He's an old guy who gives out orders and also the first one to turn into an evolved, uncomfortable state. In Lord of the Rings, you have Saruman, a powerful wizard who can totally kick anyone’s ass, and is supposed to be a good guy, but cowering under the power of the ring (I know it’s out of the story, let’s just pretend he went senile), he decides he wants to join forces with the evil likes of Sauron, and tries to talk Gandalf into doing the same, leading to a face- off between the two. He then summons and commands all these Orcs to do his bidding, as they would say.

Weird headed aliens Vs. Orcs - So you have these aliens in Bad Taste that seem to come at the protagonist and his boys in unlimited amounts, and only start looking cool towards the end of the film, but no matter how many there are, Derek and pals always seem to be able to plow right through them. In Lord Of the Rings, Frodo and the gang deal with all kinds of different monsters, which here can be presented to you as the aliens before they transform and then, when Saruman gets all pissy in his pants, he brings the orcs to life and makes them work cheap, making weapons and crap only to have them launch a full attack onto the Hobbit and his unsuspecting compatriots. Here you have the evolved state of the Aliens in Bad Taste.

Lots of Weapons Vs. Lots of Weapons - Bad Taste slaps you in the ass with pistols, shotguns, machine guns, rail guns, bazookas, chainsaws and daggers, plenty of choice weapons to rip any annoying, world conquering aliens. Lord of the Rings also gives your buttocks a fair enough slap with broadswords, short swords, magical swords, axes, daggers, bows, staffs, and nice little hats to fight the evil forces of Saruman.

Gore Vs. Gore - Bad Taste comes across as a gory film. True, you'll never see a man cut up an alien and wear its skin as a disguise in any other movie, nor will you see sheep being so brutally murdered by the good guys for no other reason then poor aim. Humans eating alien barf to hide the fact that they're human in a house of a thousand aliens who are having a slight craving for killing humans, you won't see that on Oprah.. wait, maybe you will... Anyways, LotR (short for Lord of the Rings) offers the same thing maybe on a milder level, but not much really. You've got beheadings, battles the likes Braveheart can't even compete with, a man keeping his grounds, even after being shot in the chest 3 times with arrows, a giant monster who lives in a cave and likes to smash things with his big rock bat and almost turns Frodo into squash. So far so good.

Flying SpaceShip houses Vs. Big magical flying eagles - Both these two films delve into the mystical and magical, In Bad Taste, you have a house that takes off from the ground and flies away into the sky, all magical like. In Lord of the Rings, Gandalf, when in deepest crap, is rescued by an oversized eagle to be released from his impending doom.

Lack of Ron Jeremy Vs. Lack of Ron Jeremy - You’re probably thinking to yourself, "What the hell is he talking about?!" It's ok, I get that a lot. Ron Jeremy has come forward as an icon of the year 2000. He is the swiftest gazelle you've ever seen, and he blesses the screen of over 1000 movies, most of which will be found behind those little flapping doors at your video store. But honestly folks, his face radiates any movie he ever touches. Terror Firmer, Toxie 4, Class of Nukem High 3, and all kinds of other Troma films. Now you're probably thinking, "Yeah... but who would he play in Lord of the Rings?" Easy! He could play anyone. Hobbit- he's got the physique and he's pretty hairy. Gandalf - Ron's magic has already touched many of our hearts, I can see him being a wizard, couldn't you? Now, who could he be in Bad Taste? Same rules apply. He could be an alien, he could be Derek, he could even be Ozzy. Ron Jeremy is the most multi-talented man in the world. No joke, folks.

What kind of reviewer would I be if I didn't show you both sides of the spectrum? Sure there are things these two films don't have in common, but that ’s just because of their running time.

Unrated Vs. PG-13 - The ratings are much more different, but that ’s just because Mr. Jackson toned down Lord of the Rings so that little cherubs could go see it and have a good time as well. Now Bad Taste is just little bit more bloody and aimed towards grown ups and wacky teenagers, so it ’s gotten an unrated rating because of all the blood, guts, and other bodily fluids sprayed across the screen.

109 Million $ American Vs. 150,000 $ American - There is a huge gap between budgets, but with big names (Lord of the Rings) comes big budgets. Bad Taste was an idea put together by Jackson and all the other starring characters and was shot on weekends when no one was working. Lord Of the Rings, on the other hand, is based on the popular series of books and has a lot of hype on it. If it were to be a $150,000 picture, I don't think most of the fans would be happy with the outcome, for it truly does take a big budget to accomplish such special effect feats.

So as you can see ladies and gentlemen, Lord of the Rings and Bad Taste are simply footsteps away from each other. They share the same story, characters and lack there of. They're like two neighbors who've lived along side each other but have never met. Now if I've ruined what you thought of Lord of the Rings by soiling it with Bad Taste, I apologize. This article was all written in good fun and Peter Jackson will always kick a lot of ass, no matter how big or small his budget is. This has been brought to you by the letter G, why the letter G? I don't know. 3:04A.M. END.

(I'd like to thank Adria Fillion for filling me in with all the proper names and references that I didn't know in Lord of the Rings, friggin' geek... )


[Back to Collector Times]
[Prev.] [Return to Comics] [Disclaimer] [Next]


Copyright © 2001 Jon Morrell

About the Author