Great X-pectations by Jason M. Bourgeois

Doing the Things a Spider Can

Like, oh, smashing through almost every box office record ever? Screw the X-Men. I wanna talk about Spider-Man.

This was, hands down, one of the best comic to film adaptations ever, AND a damned good movie to boot. It remained incredibly faithful to the source material, and was able to keep everything simple enough for anyone new, who had never picked up a comic, understand what the deal was with this guy.

One of the things that I feel greatly helped this film was the decision to stay as close as possible to the original source material for the characters.

This is a trend I’ve noticed more in DC movies than Marvel. Since almost any DC property is transferred to a visual, moving medium by the same folks, DC’s owner’s, AOL Time Warner, they’re able to cross-reference themselves, and do origins right. With Marvel, it seems like no two companies own more than a handful of characters. So, whenever they make plans for a new movie or tv show, unless the character is one of Marvel’s original stable, the origins have to be changed.

This is best exemplified by the Venom movie that was wandering around Hollywood some five, ten years ago. Since the rights to Spider-Man were tied up practically everywhere, and with everyone, they couldn’t even mention him in the movie, or use him in Venom’s origin.

How do you do Venom justice without any connection to Spider-Man? The character brought to screen wouldn’t be Venom, but some pissed off guy with a funky living costume. It wouldn’t be right.

Pretty much any character from the last twenty years is tied in somehow with some other character, making a lot of Marvel movies a real pain to make.

By contrast, let’s look at DC’s upcoming "Birds of Prey" series. They’re actually showing Oracle in her days as Batgirl, being shot by Joker, even showing Batman and Catwoman briefly, and sticking with the origins of the characters as closely as they can.

Sure, some things need to be changed that just won’t translate well from the printed page. The X-Men costumes are a prime example of this. Wolverine would look silly in bright canary yellow. And Green Goblin’s costume from the comics would also have much the same problems. Not that what they ended up with was much of an improvement. Under the circumstances, and thinking about it, the costume does manage to make sense, though. Maybe some in-movie explanation as to the aesthetics behind the look of the armor would have been helpful, but not necessary.

By staying as close to the source as Sony did, it also allowed them to make the movie as accessible as possible. This movie was more about Peter Parker, than Spider-Man, just like the comics. This makes the movie far more appealing once you’re sitting in the theater. You care and empathize with the Peter, since he exemplifies the typical kid in high school, with everyday problems, and gifted with great powers and abilities that allow him to face many of those problems, something many people can hook into.

All in all, Marvel and Sony, with the help of a big fan being behind the movie, and some excellent casting, made a movie that pleases both the diehard fans (Well, most of them. There are still a few with great big sticks up their collective asses, and complaining about the movie violating continuity, but that is a whole other rant), and for the newbies to jump into and enjoy just as much.

Heed this lesson, Marvel! Learn it well! Because all those people going to the movie can’t all be wrong.

In a brief bit of X-Stuff, the word reaching me about various aspects of the sequel are sounding most prominent, from casting to story. Here’s hoping we get a good sequel.


    Jason M Bourgeois


[more X-pectations] [Back to Collector Times]
[Prev.] [Return to Comics] [Disclaimer] [Next]


Copyright © 2002 Jason M. Bourgeois

About the Author