The Reader's Bookshelf

Guest Reviewer Chris Reid

Book Cover


    A Storm of Swords
    (A Song of Ice and Fire #3)

    George R. R. Martin

    Copyright © May 2002
    Bantam Books

This month’s book is an older one (at least, in the scheme of book reviews), but certainly one of the best that I’ve read. No...that’s wrong. The book is A Storm of Swords, by George R R Martin. It’s not really a book, as it doesn’t have a definable beginning nor an ending. It just is. Where it is, I can only say that it picks right up where the last chapter of the previous book left off and ends where the first chapter of the next book begins. This time, I’m not waiting two years for it to go to paperback. Maybe that’s how they get us to buy hardcover . . .

It’s impossible to talk about this book without touching on the whole storyline. It takes place in a land called the Seven Kingdoms. It is populated only by human beings (what fantasy novel is complete with out hinting at eldritch races come and passed before?), and these people live in a fairly straight out feudal society. This is a rather large continent, with many minor lords and ladies, and their households. Mr. Martin somehow manages to give the appearance of not only having each and every single member of every noble family completely worked out with their own distinct personality - but also makes you believe that he’s met each and every one of these people, sat with them, ate with them, and used their chamberpot. Hopefully not all at once.

Don’t be mistaken, it is definitely an epic. There are a few main characters, but they come and go. The story itself seems to have a life of its own. Each chapter is titled after the character it follows for it, so it seems to be almost a collection of intricately woven short stories than a book in its own right.

I have a strong belief that if you break a book down enough for a synopsis, it stops sounding original. This series holds true. It’s about a country that’s just recovered from a war, only to have its recently crowned king (who took the crown by rebellion) be killed. All of a sudden, everyone and their pet dire wolf is proclaiming themselves king. Ok, maybe not. At least a few do, though.

There are many things I like about Mr. Martin’s style. The main things are rather simple, and something you expect from any good author: Detailed characters with their own individual personalities (or lack thereof), a rather intricate plot that doesn’t necessarily show you where it’s going but rather takes you along for the ride, and a sense that the book is well-worth the money you paid for it. I can name a bunch of authors that can do that. George R R Martin can do something else, though, that set him apart from the rest. It’s a little thing that I like to call "reality."

Sure, there’s a bit of magic in the world (however uncommon), and dragons are not unheard of (although long since extinct). This is a different sort of reality. This is the reality where people, regardless of how important they are to the story, die. It’s amazing. It will make you flinch. Mr. Martin is definitely a god of his world, and he certainly likes the smite key (in case you’re wondering, it’s next to the alt key). That’s not to say that people die for no reason. That would be just as bad. People die for a reason, as important as sacrificing themselves to save their family, or for a reason as little as being silly enough to lead a charge. Not knowing which characters will live and die, and how, gives the plot its own life. Sometimes, at night, I can hear it breathing. Well, it’s either that or my stalker is back again.

Have no fear, if you read this series, you will laugh at parts, you will cry (I did when I learned how much time is between books), and you will shake your fist in righteous anger as again and again and again and again and again as characters that you felt had no right dying do so. Some of them repeatedly. But this is all good - after all, George R R Martin is writing this story, not us. Sometimes I think even he doesn’t know how it will turn out. That’s when I know that I’ll buy the next one, and every other one in this series.

Please note: Among other things, he IS a graphic writer. He puts you in his world very solidly, but it can be a violent and otherwise explicit world. If you have a weak stomach, don’t ride rollercoasters. Why you’re bringing a book up there is beyond me.

-- Chris Reid

[more Reader's Bookshelf reviews] [Back to Collector Times]
[Prev.] [Return to Reviews] [Disclaimer] [Next]

Text Copyright © 2002 Chris Reid

E-mail Chris at: Tembuki@hotmail.com