The Punisher

Review by Patrick Dunning, age 16

A little over 3 years ago in 1996, I walked away from Marvel, and in spite, said I'd never read Marvel again. I was angry with the treatment of the few Marvel titles I still read, Ghost Rider was just getting over used and ruined, that whole Onslaught mess that ruined Fantastic Four for me, and Punisher wasn't what he was anymore, he was becoming too "Superheroey". That's when I dropped it, I walked away, I went to DC mainly, and independents, for over 3 years I didn't touch a new Marvel comic, I was convinced I never would. I'm probably the last comic book geek on earth that hasn't read Kevin Smith's Daredevil run.

From what I was told hanging around the comic book store, things got a lot worse before they got better. Ghost Rider's readership went down so much they didn't bother printing the last issue. Somehow Punisher died, and became a demon killing zombie or some such nonsense. I'm told Fantastic Four got better, but I was disillusioned. That's when I heard the news, Garth Ennis was going to write Punisher.

Garth Ennis, writer/creator of Hitman, and Preacher, a sick S.O.B. by most accounts. The man who wrote Hitman puking on Batman's boots, the man who wrote about a one eyed preacher looking for God to kick his ass into going back to heaven, the man that's written more gore then Stephen King probably has. I heard he was throwing out the demon hunter crap and getting back to what The Punisher was, a serial killing sociopath. He'd be writing a 12 issue maxi-series returning Frank Castle to his roots.

So after much thought, I decided, I would *gasp* buy a Marvel comic. I went to the comic book store expecting to buy 2 Marvel comics that day "The Punisher #1", and the reprinted "The Punisher Kills the Marvel Universe" also written by Garth Ennis. I was disappointed to find "TPKtMU" was delayed a week.

Anyhow, on to The Punisher #1. When I saw it, the first thing I noticed was it's amazing cover art, it really served it's purpose of drawing you in. You open to a panel one, page one, and already see corpses, something that you see a lot of in this issue. In this issue, Garth Ennis firmly establishes the tone for this maxi, brutal. You will get a lot in this issue, the carnage is a given, you see Frank giving a guy a chance to straighten himself out, you get a glimpse of Frank's supporting cast, a quick, short, reasonable explanation for the whole lame demon killer thing, humor, a realistic looking arsenal, machine gunning, grenading, knifing, shot gunning, and good ol' fashion hands on approach, I count 17 casualties and it's only issue 1! Despite the high body count within the issue, it surprisingly sounds reasonable in context. Garth Ennis has, so far, accomplished bringing back the good ol' Punisher I used to know and er, um read regularly.

Looking to the future, Garth Ennis promises "Creative use of a flamethrower in issue #3", more violence, mean ass villains, and a lot more machine gunning. If he can keep the pace up that he has in issue one, I believe this will be, as hyped "THE book of 2000". I recommend this book highly, really highly, and probably have, during the year, a mid series review when issue #6 comes out, and an ending review of the series at well, the end. And on that note . . .


[Back to Collector Times]
[Prev.] [Return to Comics] [Disclaimer] [Next]


Review Copyright © 2000 Patrick Dunning

confused2often@hotmail.com

About the Author