A Matter of Tradition
By Mike Solko

Nearly any comic collector who has spent time at online forums has no doubt found themselves entangled in some sort of debate over continuity and the effect it has on the comic book industry. My own personal feeling toward this is that continuity is important in some instances but that most comics, especially those with histories running over half a century, need to look forward in their goals. At the same time, it’s important for companies to look back and nod towards what has come before. As I’ve thought back towards my past 20 years as a collector. I struggled hard to come up with a term for what keeps me coming back to the shop week after week and only one word seemed to fit the bill: tradition.

Although less prevalent in comics today than they were in the past, there were certain traditional elements that tended to show up in stories which didn’t detract for a reader who had no foreknowledge of the situation but could grow to appreciate it. Some examples that immediately spring to mind are leadership elections in the Legion of Super Heroes, red kryptonite stories in Superman, or a massive shift in the Avengers line-up. To me these stories and others could make me feel like a part of something that my uncles were a part of before me and so on.

Of all traditional types of stories, the one that had the greatest influence on me as a reader was the annual Justice Society of America/Justice League of America team-ups. The Justice League was still going strong when I began reading their exploits around 1980. The Superfriends/Big Gun type characters like Superman and Wonder Woman were active members while less known characters such as Red Tornado, Zatanna and Firestorm fleshed out the team. At this point, I knew that most of the major DC heroes had been around for a very long time, but had no idea that the Superman or Hawkman who lived when my parents were kids was still alive and well, just on another planet. The fact that these Golden Age heroes were still active, just on a different planet Earth was the coolest thing to me and never went over my head!

Pinning down what attracted me so much to the crossovers between the two teams is difficult to narrow down, but is helped some when looking back at the first JLA/JSA crossover I read, the Crisis in Limbo series from 1981. Super villains from Earth 1 and Earth 2 had teamed up as the Secret Society of Super Villains and agreed to pick off the members of both super teams. Five members from each of the Justice groups are picked off one by one thanks to the villains and are shot into limbo. Thanks to some squabbling among the villains, the heroes break out of limbo and through a supreme effort of teamwork prove they are the greatest heroes of two worlds. Pretty cheesy by modern standards, but at the time I was still young enough to believe that the heroes really were in severe trouble and to be cheering for months every time I saw the heroes saving the day.

Over the next few years, I was a pretty avid JLA reader but there was always that little something extra that seemed to come out for the JSA crossovers. How cool was it to find out that not only was Per Degaton now the dictator of the WWII era Earth 2, but Earth Prime (otherwise known as the real world we live in) had been devastated by a nuclear attack. To stop Per Degaton it took the combined efforts of the JSA, JLA and the All-Star Squadron to stop him. This five issue crossover also featured the Crime Syndicate of Earth 3 who were recently revived in the popular Grant Morrison penned JLA: Earth 2 graphic novel.

Some of the other crossovers that spring to mind brought forth developments such as the truth about Black Canary and her mother, rescuing the Seven Soldiers of Victory who were scattered across time and a murder mystery where one of the heroes murdered Mr. Terrific! Many characters who weren’t directly affiliated with either the JLA or JSA would show up to lend a hand on occasion including the Legion of Super Heroes, the Freedom Fighters, the Marvel Family, the All Star-Squadron and others. With the crossovers running as an annual tradition for 22 years this brief recollection doesn’t even begin to include the majority of stories involved. With such a lasting duration these crossovers really set a precedent for crossovers that are still occurring in comic books today.

The eventual downfall of the annual crossovers sprung from the Crisis on Infinite Earths, DC’s attempt at cleaning up continuity which is still being sorted out over 15 years later. Because the idea of multiple earths existing was thrown out the window, the Justice Society could no longer exist concurrently with the Justice League. Although the JSA was revealed to be still somewhat active through modern times they were quickly sent off to fight in Valhalla so as not to confuse fans as to why these old guys calling themselves Green Lantern and Flash were running around. Most of the crossovers that took place in the past still occurred in continuity with a semi-active JSA teaming with their successors in special situations. As far as the powers that be were concerned, the Justice Society was a dead issue at this point and it was time to move forward with the DC Universe.

Last year Grant Morrison’s JLA title featured the first crossover with the Justice Society to take place in over a decade and served as a lead in to the new JSA series which is going strong. With both teams existing in a universe at the same time, it is once again possible for the annual tradition to begin once again and with some of the nostalgia movement going on, I can see this as becoming a very big thing again. If the creative teams of the two books were to work together on a story that would be fairly significant in nature, they could tell the story between the two titles and still have 10 or 11 months to tell stories the rest of the year.

From what I understand, there were tentative plans for a JLA/JSA crossover to take place in the near future which would introduce the new Hawkman to the DC universe. Due to scheduling problems, the story will be taking place only in the JSA title and won’t feature the JLA, though. This near miss is enough to make my heart sink but at the same time, the hope is still out there that a crossover will work out down the line. By planning to introduce an important character, it tells me that the powers that be have the right idea as to where they should go with this if they proceed in the future. Maybe if they can’t fit a crossover into the monthly title then maybe they could work it into the annuals.

In the future, I plan to cover traditions both in matters of what occurs in fiction and in reality in the comic industry. If there are any sort of traditions you’d like to see discussed here please e-mail me and let me know, or just drop me a line to let me know what you think of the column in general.


[Back to Collector Times]
[Prev.] [Return to Opinion] [Disclaimer] [Next]


Copyright © 2000 Mike Solko

frost@ncinternet.net